Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Cold Case Christianity

Christian Case Making

The Struggle Between Presenting Arguments and Being Argumentative

The Struggle Between Presenting Arguments And Being Argumentative
Image Credit: Edmond Dantès from Pexels

If you’re interested in “apologetics” (the defense of the Christian faith), you’re probably interested in arguments. Not the “heated, angry exchanges between people who hold opposing views” (one definition of the term), but “the reason or set of reasons given with the aim of persuading others that an claim is right or wrong.” Christian apologists engage the second definition of the term: What’s the best argument for Christianity? How can we refute the arguments of atheists or other non-believers? How can we convince someone else to believe what we believe?

Sometimes it’s easy for me to get too focused on making the argument. I know the reasons why I believe what I believe, and when I hear an objection my first impulse is to spell out all the reasons the person I’m talking to is wrong. My passion for my beliefs can lead me to be aggressive in my pursuit of winning the intellectual debate. Sometimes I can be so focused on “winning” the argument that I can become argumentative.

Therein lies one of the biggest problems we can run into as defenders of the faith. It’s easy to become so focused on the truth of the arguments that I lose sight of the person I am talking to. If I “win” the argument, but alienate the person, I’ve missed the point entirely. It is my hope that I might evangelize through effective apologetics, but I can’t lose sight of the goal along the way: I want to bring other people to Christ.

During Jesus’ famous Sermon on the Mount, He said, “You are the light of the world. A town built on a hill cannot be hidden. Neither do people light a lamp and put it under a bowl. Instead they put it on its stand, and it gives light to everyone in the house. In the same way, let your light shine before others, that they may see your good deeds and glorify your Father in heaven.” (Matthew 5:14-16). During this passage, Jesus compared us to “light” which draws people out of the darkness. He also reminded us of the importance of goodness (“good deeds”). We are called to interact with others to draw them out of the darkness while demonstrating the character of Jesus along the way.

Jesus is our role model in this regard. One of the many complaints the Pharisees had about Jesus was that he would associate with sinners. Jesus would dine at the house of tax collectors, associate with prostitutes, and the religious leaders of that day found this behavior abhorrent. But Jesus developed a relationship with these sinners and called them out of the darkness. Jesus loved them and they knew it. He opened the door for his message.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

And His message wasn’t always easy.

Jesus did not sugarcoat the Word of God; He spoke about the majesty of God and the depravity of humans. He called out the hypocrisy of the religious leaders and turned over the tables of the money lenders when appropriate. Jesus demonstrated the balance between mercy and justice. He calls us to do the same. In my love for apologetics, in my love for the arguments, even in my love for arguing, I don’t want to lose sight of the purpose of the apologetics: to bring people to a faith in Jesus. Share on X

I sometimes fall into one extreme or the other: speaking in love to the point in which I avoid or misrepresent hard truths or speaking the truth so adamantly that I no longer have a loving approach. If I am loving to those around me but fail to speak the Gospel message, then I am no longer being an effective follower of Christ. But if I speak the truth without love or in a way which turns off my audience, then I am similarly ineffective. I want to keep my focus on Jesus’ example and strive to be a great communicator. In my love for apologetics, in my love for the arguments, even in my love for arguing, I don’t want to lose sight of the purpose of the apologetics: to bring people to a faith in Jesus.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Written By

Jimmy Wallace is a detective who holds a BA in Psychology (from UCLA) and an MA in Theology - Applied Apologetics (from Colorado Christian University).



  1. Letha "The Grinch" Bice

    January 1, 2021 at 8:55 am

    Part of what I posted on today – “J. Warner Wallace (Jim), a homicide detective, is in a family of cops like the series “Blue Bloods”. He has often said that Christians need to think like a detective (cop). I agree with that, and his statement: “Many Christians just don’t know how to communicate the Truth.” I believe that we need to take his advice of thinking like cops even when it comes to talking with atheists and getting them to tell the truth about why they “believe” like they do. Jesus is Authority, and He has given us Authority: “Whatever you loose, I will loose; whatever you bind, I will bind.” A cop is an authority in the earth. So, we need to study how cops operate. In cop shows, like “Blue Bloods”, you often see the good cop/bad cop routine used by a cop and his partner. The good or bad cop controls the interrogating, depending on who they are talking to, and the other one steps in when one isn’t getting anywhere. Jesus sent His disciples out in two’s. Probably for safety – and very possibly for an effective partnership. For a long time, Christians have been conditioned to just play the role of the good cop. Therefore, they aren’t real effective in getting someone to fess up to what’s really going on inside of them. Jesus, the great communicator, always knew which role to play. And, we can learn to do the same. This takes a lot of training. Being a witness for Christ is not just knowing what Jesus said. We have to study the way that He said it, and to whom He said it. Since the fall created “flipped” thinking – we often find ourselves getting flipped in our conversations with people.”

  2. Keith Walker

    October 18, 2021 at 10:45 am

    This is a wonderfully succinct article. Isaac Newton is quoted as having said that tact is the art of making a point without making an enemy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Christian Case Making

I’ve been writing recently about jury selection. If you are interested in making a case for what you believe as a Christian, you probably...

Evangelism and Case Making

In this podcast, J. Warner chats with Peyton Jones and Pete Mitchell, the hosts of the Church Planter Podcast about the challenges of church...

Christian Case Making

As an investigator, I made a living conducting interviews. In fact, my agency repeatedly utilized me when they needed someone to confess to a...


In this podcast, J. Warner talks about four simple strategies to help strengthen the faith and understanding of young believers. How can parents help...