Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Cold Case Christianity

Belief / Faith

Should Our Faith Remain “Evidence Free”?

Should Our Faith Remain Evidence Free
Image Credit: Emily Rose from Pexels

“Faith is believing in something that cannot be proven and for which there is no evidence.”

Media representations of religious people would make you think this is an almost universally held opinion. “Faith and religion just can’t be proven by evidence.” “They just have to be believed.” It seems like there is a certain disconnect between the way people think about matters of faith and the way they think about the rest of life. It is as though people believe faith (by its nature) is somehow less “real” or “demonstrable” than other facts of life.

It is important to think about what evidence actually is, as well as what it isn’t. Often in movies we will hear about the “smoking gun,” a single piece of evidence which is so strong that it can prove a suspect committed a crime. In reality, few pieces of evidence like this exist in criminal cases. All pieces of evidence are part of a bigger puzzle and many of the pieces are open to debate.

In some cases, we might be lucky to have an eyewitness who saw the crime occur. When the witness testifies in court, the defense attorney may question the strength of the eyewitness account. What did the witness see? Was the witness somewhere where they would have seen enough to identify the suspect? Is the witness a trustworthy person in the first place? In other cases, we might have DNA left at the crime scene. Even in these cases, the defense may have many legitimate questions. Was the person who recovered the DNA properly trained to collect the evidence? Was the DNA tested accurately? Was there any other way the suspect’s DNA could have been at the scene (maybe he was at the location long before the crime occurred)? Even the confession of a suspect may be open to debate. Was the suspect coerced into confessing to the crime? Was the suspect in his right mind to make such a confession?

Even without witnesses, even without DNA evidence, and even without a confession by the suspect, cases are solved and suspects are convicted every day in our country.  Imagine that. Crimes committed in secret, with no one around, for which there is no physical evidence, are solved and suspects are caught. In these cases, it might be worth asking whether the crimes even occurred in the first place. In fact, establishing that a crime occurred is one of the first things established in any court case.

In a current case I am investigating, I have been contacting the victims to coordinate their court appearances. In this case, the suspects broke into a series of homes while the residents were gone. The victims did not see the suspects commit the crime and will have to appear in court to explain why they believe they were victimized. Many will tell their stories of coming home to find broken doors and windows, ransacked homes, and finding their property missing. The defense will have the opportunity to question even these basic facts of the case. From the law enforcement side, the district attorney will need to make a compelling argument to the jury that a crime occurred. The victims did not see the crime occur but can deduce that they had been victimized by the effects the crime had on their lives (such as the broken windows or missing property). The victim’s observations about the condition of their homes is itself a piece of evidence.

In some ways, many crimes become abstract. Unless video evidence exists to show the crime occurring, the crime exists largely in the mind of the jury. The jury ultimately must wrestle with the evidence they have been presented and answer two key questions: 1) Did a crime occur? 2) Was the suspect presented in court the person who committed that crime? Only if both questions are “Yes” will the suspect be convicted.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

The case for Christianity is no more or less abstract than the typical criminal case. Christianity makes several key claims about things which have occurred, and evidence exists related to those claims. It is up to us as individuals to question the claims and evidence of Christianity, to question each piece of evidence and come to a conclusion – one way or the other.

To simply dismiss Christianity as being something which cannot be proven, or for which no evidence can be offered, is to reveal a bias. If we treat faith as something less “real” than the rest of our lives, it shouldn’t surprise us to find that many conclude it is not real. Claims about faith can and should be investigated just as any claim made in a courtroom. To simply dismiss Christianity as being something which cannot be proven, or for which no evidence can be offered, is to reveal a bias. - Jimmy Wallace Click To Tweet

Detective Jimmy Wallace (J. Warner’s son) is a Police Investigator in Los Angeles County, a Christian Case Maker, host of the Incarnate Investigation Podcast and Incarnate Investigation Video Series (featured at ColdCaseChristianity.com).

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Written By

Jimmy Wallace (J. Warner's son) holds a BA in Psychology (from UCLA) and is currently completing his MA in Theology - Applied Apologetics (from Colorado Christian University).

1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. Daniel Cox

    January 25, 2021 at 5:53 pm

    The standards evidence in court are not good, rather they the best we can do and are necessary for a functioning society. This standard is simply too low for extraordinary claims that Christianity makes. When someone is tried for murder we have a huge amount of evidence that people do get murdered. The purpose is to find out who did it. With the resurrection of Jesus we don’t even know if it’s possible never mind it’s likelihood. Extraordinary exclaims require one to provide more evidence because we know less about them. Perhaps this is where the stereotype of faith over evidence comes from. You can’t make huge claims about the world and use legal and historical standards of evidence.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like

Christianity

Is there a reason so many famous scientists from history were Jesus-followers? Is there something about the Christian worldview that encourages an exploration of...

Belief / Faith

Christian writer Mark Mittelberg, writing in his work The Questions Christians Hope No One Will Ask, posed the following question, “Didn’t evolution put God...

Christianity

Are minds the same as brains? If they aren’t, how can we tell them apart? What evidence do we have to make such a...

Christianity

Are we nothing more than material beings? Are we “soulish” creatures? Are we simply bodies with brains, or are we souls with minds? What...